Chica, this is a great idea! Unfortunately I can't make it on Oct. 10, but I hope you'll get enough interest to make it happen!
The Spanish restaurant we go to is La Encina, on route 3 in East Goshen. Its web site is
http://www.laencinarestaurant.com/index.htm You can read the menu, check out prices, get directions, etc.
The food is very good! The tapas are excellent, as are the entrees and desserts. The olive oil sorbet is unusual but delicious!(And the recipe is a secret.) The tarta de Santiago is out of this world. The pulpo on the aperitivos menu is probably the best I've ever tasted, anywhere! I've had it on two separate occasions, and I highly recommend it! The paella IS good, HOWEVER -- a word of warning - it is spiced very differently than your standard Spanish paella. If you order the paella hoping to get a taste of Spain, you may be disappointed. If you order it to try a new twist, you'll probably be impressed. The menu offers a great mix of traditionally delicious Spanish dishes and the chef's own excellent creations based on typical ingredients used in Spain.
Hope things work out!