If you are in Manhattan I would really recommend Centro Español
239 West 14th Street, New York
(212) 243-9308 for a very authentic experience. I was there last night for the first time. When you enter you immediately feel like you are in Spain...with the customers ( men in
boinas playing dominos, the aromas of Spanish food cooking and, of course, everyone speaking Spanish). That room leads into a dining room which is a bit less casual, yet not at all fancy. We were three people. We had 3 tapas:
sardinas a la plancha, aceitunas aliñadas y el plato casero--queso manchego, jamón serrano and chorizo . For dinner we ordered a
paella ( which was
so good--especially the rice that was sticking to the pan--showing it was cooked in the
paellera )
,
pollo al ajillo y merluza a la vasca---
We also ordered 2 bottles of wine...no dessert or coffee though. The bill was $120--we thought it was reasonable for what we had eaten. All in all, I would highly recommend this restaurant if you want a good Spanish restaurant that is simple yet very authentic.